Ubuntu Bugzilla Migration Comment Cleanup
Earlier in the year, we migrated the bugs from bugzilla.ubuntu.com
over to Launchpad. This process
involved changes to the bug numbers, since the
Launchpad is used for more than just
Ubuntu and already had a number of bugs
reported in the system.
People often refer to other bugs in comments, which both Bugzilla and Launchpad conveniently turn into links. The changed bug numbers meant that the bug references in the comments ended up pointing to the wrong bugs. The bug import was done one bug at a time, so if bug A referred to bug B but bug B hadn't been imported by the time we were importing bug A, then we wouldn't know what bug number it should be referring to.
The solution we used was to just insert a link to the bug watch URL
(e.g.
https://launchpad.net/malone/bugtrackers/ubuntu-bugzilla/$BUGID),
which allowed people to find the referenced bug, but was a bit ugly.
Today we ran a fixup script to remove these bug watch URLs from comments and rewrite the old Bugzilla bug numbers to the current Launchpad bug numbers. This cleans up the old imported bugs a bit so they fit in better with the bugs entered directly into Launchpad.
Comments:
Rudd-O -
Wasn't it easier to perform a topological sort before doing the import? A bit of Python grease would have done it ;-)
James Henstridge -
Rudd-O: That wouldn't be possible with a one-bug-at-a-time conversion. Consider the following chain of events:
1. Alice files bug 42 2. Bob files bug 43 about the same issue 3. Charles adds a comment to bug 42 saying that bug 43 looks like a duplicate 4. Alice closes bug 43 making a comment that it is a duplicate of bug 42.
Which order do you import the two bugs?